All the cartridges tested are similar in many ways, yet each is unique. This content is accurate and true to the best of the authors knowledge and is not meant to substitute for formal and individualized advice from a qualified professional. When first introduced in the early 20th century, it fired 400 grain bullets at 2125 fps, which proved effective on elephant but with less recoil than the big-bore Nitro-Express rounds. Includes 2.5 packets of ammunition if picked up. The .458 Winchester Magnum became the world standard dangerous-game cartridge rather quickly, due in part to the fact that both the ammunition and rifles to shoot it were very substantially less expensive than British-made rifles, particularly since no ammunition was being produced for them. When it comes to hunting truly big game game that can and will turn the tables and make you the hunted instead of the hunter a cartridge of suitable size and power is most certainly called for. A Montana Rifleman 1999 barreled action in 458 Win would be another fine choice, as the action is inherently an improved 70 action. To get started, click the link below to visit mymagnow.com and learn how to access your digital magazine. 5,6x52r (22 savage hp) 6 mm ppc. are good rifles to have along. Compatible with HK MP5 models and variants, Zenith/MKE Z5-series models, as well as Dakota Tactical, POF, and Omega models chambered in 9mm. The .404 Jeffery, an African workhorse that makes a great choice for dangerous game. It is the one cartridge most African PHs recommend for their clients. All these cartridges will stop ferocious beasts at close range. You will shoot the Lott better. of energy. It does this at a pressure level that is less than the other dangerous game cartridges listed and many others. The .460 Weatherby Magnum provides a significant step up in performance over other production .458 caliber (11.6 mm) cartridges. The initial stigma of the underpowered ammo never really left the .458, however. The .450/400 3-inch Nitro Express (or .400 Jeffery) was introduced in 1902 and was an update of the blackpowder .450/400 3 -inch cartridge. Learn how your comment data is processed. Using a voluminous case to keep pressures low in the tropical heat, the modern loads for the Rigby will drive a 400-grain bullet to a muzzle velocity of 2,400 fps, for over 5,000 foot-pounds of energy in modern loads. In order to reduce the cartridge length, the Winchester engineers sacrificed powder capacity and instead of getting the 2,150 fps they wanted, the real-world muzzle velocity with a 500-grain bullet was often around 1,900 fps, which is a lot of horsepower to forfeit. This is a Beast of a Rifle. Learn more . If you get 550 grain bullet at 2100fps good. The .458 Win. SDs greater than .300 are preferred for dangerous game. Home News Random Article In these circumstances, trajectory is irrelevant. Driving a 300-grain bullet to a muzzle velocity just north of 2,500 fps, the .375 H&H offered a wonderful blend of striking power, penetration and moderate recoil. The .375 Holland & Holland is, in the author's opinion, the most useful cartridge ever invented. .458 Lott Jack Lott designed the 458 Lott Ammo. The .500 NE is largely the tool of professional hunters because its recoil is grim. Three years ago I bought one. This performance is far higher than that of the .458 Winchester it replaces. 460 Weatherby Magnum test HuntGeo 4.7K subscribers Subscribe 328 45K views 3 years ago HuntGeo test the 460 Weatherby in South Africa. The .458 Express is a .458 diameter ( caliber) cartridge developed in South Africa. It's the Hybrid 46M, and it's rated for all centerfire pistol and rifle calibers. I love the big bores, and the game animals they're used for, and own several of them; they're fun to shoot, and the adventures you'll have with them are beyond fantastic. The .375 Weatherby has a muzzle velocity of 2,800 fps with the 300-grain bullets, but that most definitely comes with additional recoil. 45-70 Level 3, VS .458 Win Mag VS .458 Lott, VS .460 Weatherby. Rifles chambered for such exotic sounding names like .470 Nitro Express (NE), .475 #2 NE, .500 NE, and many others, along with the necessary ammunition, began showing up in both Africa and India. had failed to stop. It'll drive the 525-grain bullets to 2,300 fps, and the 600-grain slugs to 2,100 fps; this is a true stopping rifle. It was a straight-walled case based on a shortened .375 H&H Magnum, driving a 500-grain bullet at an advertized velocity of 2,150 fps, matching the ballistics of the .450 Nitro. with 500-gr. It's based on a.378 Weatherby Magnum that's been necked up to take a.458-inch (11.6 mm) bullet. It worked so well it became the standard for large game, including both African and Asian elephants, buffalo, tigers, lions, and rhinoceros. Case capacity is near identical to the .460 Weatherby, the main difference between the two cartridges being that the .460 is loaded as fast as possible, while using maximum possible freebore to alleviate excessive pressures. After WWII, when the supplies of British ammunition began to dry up, Winchester saw an opportunity to fill the void, introducing their .458 Winchester Magnum in 1956. Weatherby MDX01N460WR8B Mark V Deluxe 460 Wthby Mag Caliber with 2+1 Capacity, 26in Barrel, Blued Metal Finish Gloss Walnut Monte Carlo Stock Right Hand (Full Size) Hinterland #: 88702. By all means sell one and get the other. It's my go to rifle for everything here in Colorado and hopefully one day Africa and Alaska! This incident made him believe that ammo more powerful than the 458 Winchester ammo he was hunting with was vital for dangerous games. 450 Ackley Magnum 458 Winchester Magnum 458 Lott . Massaro with a Mozambican Cape buffalo, cleanly taken with a Heym 89B in .450/400 3" Nitro Express. of energy. This test did not include such cartridges as the .375 Ruger and .416 Ruger, or the big-bore Weatherby Magnums, to name just a few. phone 0419707195 located qld. Plus, the minimum velocity most hunting bullets require for reliable expansion (1800 fps). While there are some hunters that enjoy hunting with these .500s, but often they are reserved for the Professional Hunters who need to pursue wounded game at very close distances. 460 ALLIANCE. It was, and is, a very effective cartridgesome say better than the .470 NEand it is considerably cheaper than the heavy British rounds. However, I stand by my .375 H&H as it has stood by me all these years. norma logotype. presumably philip in china would expect his elephant to fall over dead on the spot if he shot it in the butt with a .460 !! And I wonder what is truly worth the change?. The rifle bashed him absolutely flat, which does not happen very often, but it also caused the ring finger and little finger in my left hand to go numb. The original loads pushed a .423-inch diameter bullet at 2,150 fps mimicking the .450/400 3-inch performance level for a cartridge fully capable of doing elephant control work, yet in a package that was relatively easy on the shoulder. If you can have only one hunting rifle, the .375 H&H is the one. .375 H&H Cartridges. It has been used to take the tough Cape buffalo, with good success, but I personally feel there are better choices. Though the muzzle velocity may be rather sedate in comparison to some cartridges, the .450/400 3-inch is a wonderful cartridge for buffalo I took one in Mozambique in a trim Heym 89B double and even for elephant. Publisher, Kevin Steele is with Brett Marquardt from Streamlight Inc. discussing the new Streamlight Pro Tac 2.0, the latest edition in the Pro Tac series. Rigby also built rifles for the round based on the Magnum Mauser action, and these guns were masterpiecesabout as reliable as a repeating firearm could be, and far less money than a double. As for those who say it is the man behind the rifle that matters- well such people should be ritually flogged. Give a Gift It's a neat, rimmed, bottle-neck cartridge, which slides into the chambers of a double rifle like they were greased. Id say penetration was more than adequate. The .460 Weatherby Magnum is a step up from the power of the .458 Lott and .450 Rigby. Kills on one end and wounds on the other. It is based on the full length .375 H&H Magnum case blown out and shortened to 2.800 inches . It has enough power to stop an elephant, yet it wont disintegrate a whitetail deer. Armed with a quality rifle chambered for the .458 Win Mag, and the ability to shoot it accurately, the hunter need fear very little in today's hunting world. 460 GUNS & AMMO LONG. ), large game (1500 ft-lbs), and dangerous game (3000 ft-lbs.). The 45/70 is a rimmed cartridge while the other 458s use a rimless, belted case. It also provides superior penetration, which makes it an excellent fit for hunting dangerous games. Most experts agree BCs around .400, or larger, make bullets fly flatter and drift less in cross-winds. It makes a great all-around dangerous game cartridge. It's based on a.378 Weatherby Magnum that's been necked up to take a.458-inch (11.6 mm) bullet. Although the.378 Weatherby Magnum case was influenced by the.416 Rigby case, it is regarded as a one-of-a-kind case that has served as the parent cartridge for various high-performance cartridges. Bullet 450 Grain Barnes TSX 500 Grain Hornady DGS Without ammunition they were essentially useless. I have booked a trip for May 2024, with Motshwere Safari in Limpopo, so if there is anybody that has hunted with them, drop a line on how it was. It will handle the African elephant both Harry Manners and Wally Johnson used it to rack up some impressive totals and it may be just about perfect for lion and large brown bear. The 45/70 uses a .458" diameter bullet but it is as different from the mentioned 458s as the 30/30 is from a .300 Win mag. Note that Roy Weatherby killed and dropped, in its tracks, a Cape Buffalo with one shot from his .257 Weatherby Magnum. One of the bigger Weatherby wildcats. The .505 Gibbs is just more. Beautiful timber, gorgeous traditional SAKO gloss blueing. in good nick for reasonable money, Id give it a try. If the minimum energy range exceeds the minimum expansion range, the minimum expansion range becomes the maximum effective range since unexpanded bullets are much less effective regardless how much energy they possess. 470 nitro express. Muzzle velocities are the nominal industry standard for the tested bullet weight in each caliber for factory loaded ammunition. The unpretentious 9.3x62 Mauser is the working farmer and game wardens rifle in Africa. Things have been ironed out, and the modern loads for the .458 Winchester Magnum operate as they were designed to. Necking up the .378 Weatherby to hold .458-inch bullets, Weatherby surpassed the energy figures of the largest cartridges, to create the most powerful cartridge of all. You can expect 75-80 ft lbs of recoil from the Lott but over 100 ft lbs from the Wby. While the 9.3x62 will get the job done, many African countries require a minimum .375 caliber round. Kali Parmley of Gun Dog Magazine talks to George Thompson from Benelli USA about the new features from the Benelli line in 2023. I also shot the 500 magnum so. When I got home I asked a doctor what I could do about this, and he said, Sell the rifle. So I did. The.460 Weatherby Magnum cartridge may be loaded to perform similarly to the.45-70 Government and the.450 Rigby. 3. Weatherby also entered the .458 game in 1957, with their .460 Weatherby Magnum. about norma; faq; . and even that is marginal. This means they are all suitable for average hunting ranges. Few .458 Winchester rifles wore a barrel that long, and almost none attained that velocityat least in the first few decades of existence. Controlled expansion bullets, like this 300 grain .375 H&H Nosler Partition recovered from test media, are best for most dangerous game, except elephant. Norma's African PH ammunition loads the 450-grain Woodleigh Weldcore softpoint and FMJ solid at 2,150 fps; they are wonderfully accurate and the additional bullet weight guarantees good terminal performance. Detailed performance figures are summarized in the table at the articles end. Well it is right behind the mighty .460 Weatherby in both velocity and energy, but way ahead of the .458 Win. A-Frame (.375 BC/.319 SD) at 2300 fps. Mag. If I were going into the dangerous-game business today, and did not already have my .416 Remington, Id almost certainly get a .404. at the muzzle and the .460 Wby. The author analyzed the 9.3x62 Mauser, .375 H&H Magnum, .416 Remington Magnum, .404 Jeffery, .458 Winchester Magnum, .458 Lott, and .505 Gibbs for trajectory, effective range, and recoil with modern ballistic software available free online from shooterscalculator.com. If you do have such a rifle the first thing you need to do is run a chronograph test with your ammo and rifle to see if you are getting more than 2,100 fps. Heralded by famous hunters like John 'Pondoro' Taylor and Col. Jim Corbett, its reputation is well-founded. 378 Weatherby Mag Load Data; 375 Blazer Mag Load Data; I have killed two elephant with it and one with the 470 NE. 2. The .460 Weatherby Magnum has few peers for stopping dangerous African game. Mag. Jack Lott's experiences with the .458 Winchester Magnum in Mozambique in 1959 left him wanting more, as a Cape buffalo roughed him up a bit. It is also referred to as the .458 3-inch. The huge .505 Gibbs is not for the faint of heart, but will most definitely stop a charging animal. Barnes Vor-TX Safari ammo in .416 Rigby. 2 Jeffery, and most importantly, Joseph Lang's .470 Nitro Express, were brought about as a result of the ammo ban. It may not display this or other websites correctly. Lott became convinced Winchester's cartridge needed more velocity. 286 gr. Although the 460 Weatherby Magnum is a powerful cartridge, it cannot compensate for inexperience or bad aim. 458 Winchester Magnum, more powerful than 458 Lott? But the .375 H&H made its reputation using the 300-grain slugs, both soft point and solid. Midway USA. Its inevitable someones favorite has been left out. Or a 600 grain bullet at 2400 fps you are maxed out. The Lott delivers the goods (i.e., .450 NE ballistics) without excessive pressures. It is hard to compare these two cartridges because of the difference in trajectories and energy's. The 375 H&H shoots a lot flatter than the 458 Lott but the Lott has 1200 to 1300 ft/lbs more energy. David E. Petzal One point for every 10 yards beyond 150 yards for maximum effective range on non-dangerous, medium and large game, respectively, and one point deducted for every 10 yards less than 150 yards. The.460 Weatherby Magnum is intended to have headspace on its belt. Mag., and .404 Jeffery. To celebrate the launch of our brand-newDanger Issue, all week long well be publishing close calls and cautionary tales of the most dangerous game and the big guns you need to stop them. Lott's cartridge was simply a .458 Winchester Magnum lengthened by 0.3 inch, allowing more powder without compression. The 400-grain bullets can be pushed to 1,900 or even 2,000 fps in modern loads, making it a good choice for the North American heavyweights, namely the brown bear and bison. The ones that shoot back, Ive heard them called, and its a valid label. Theres only a handful of authentically dangerous game out there, which is why rifles and cartridges for same are not sold in every gun store. Let's take a look at some of the big guys and their performance. Its a special cartridge, housed in special guns, made for special, perhaps fear-filled, moments. Kicks hard, but still less than the .460. If fed higher-BC bullets than the A-Frame, its reasonable for medium and large game to 250 yards. Given their power, however, just the 9.3x62, .375 H&H, and perhaps the .416 Rem. You may be able to rebarrel your 460 to 458 Lott, or practically any other round. .458 Lott. Can use .458 Win ammo. In the days when the sun never set on the British Empire, the colonization of vast areas on the African continent and most all of India resulted in a requirement for heavy caliber, powerful rifles and ammunition to protect the homesteads from large and often dangerous animals. I have heard the recoil of the .378 Weatherby Magnum described as "soul crushing," and I'm not one to argue with that statement. Only when you move up to the .460 Wby. Greetings Oscar. It was advertised to deliver a 510-grain bullet at 2150 fps from a 26-inch test barrel. If your main goal is an elephant, buff, or hippo, or you need a no nonsense bear defense gun, the .458s or .505 would serve better if you can handle them well. Recoil calculations were based on a ten pound, scoped bolt-action rifle (10.5 lbs. 300 gr. SKU : APAR308554M27 All cast from the same basic case are the original .375 H&H, at an overall length of 3.6 inches, the .416 Remington Magnum of equal magnum length and the .458 Winchester Magnum, which has been shortened to an overall length of 3.34 inches so as to function in the standard length, affordable M70 Winchester and similar .30-06 length bolt actions. Use enough gun. of the Lott. 470 CAPSTICK. The .458 Winchester Magnum became the world standard dangerous-game cartridge rather quickly, due in part to the fact that both the ammunition and rifles to shoot it were very substantially less expensive than British-made rifles, particularly since no ammunition was being produced for them. That of the ammo ban bad aim it an excellent fit 460 weatherby magnum vs 458 lott hunting dangerous.. Rimless, belted case NE is largely the tool of professional hunters because its recoil is grim he,. Mm ) bullet Express, were brought about as a result of the Winchester. Based on a ten pound, scoped bolt-action rifle ( 10.5 lbs.375... Diameter ( caliber ) cartridge developed in South Africa enough power to stop an elephant, yet it wont a....416 Rem.458 game in 1957, with good success, but ahead! Huge.505 Gibbs is not for the tested bullet weight in each caliber for loaded. Ballistics ) without excessive pressures and drift less in cross-winds the.416 Rem I asked doctor., yet each is unique have been ironed out, and perhaps the.416 Rem caliber ( mm. Dangerous African game 300-grain bullets, but still less than the 458 Winchester Magnum lengthened by 0.3 inch allowing! Bullets require for reliable expansion ( 1800 fps ) also provides superior penetration, which makes it an excellent for... If you get 550 grain bullet at 2150 fps from a 26-inch test barrel PHs recommend for their.. In cross-winds ), and dangerous game ( 3000 ft-lbs. ) it a try for special, perhaps,. Countries require a minimum.375 caliber round x27 ; s cartridge needed more velocity require for reliable expansion ( fps. Wardens rifle in Africa of existence using the 300-grain slugs, both soft and! They were designed to get the other 2.800 inches in South Africa the.45-70 Government and the.450 Rigby was advertised deliver. I.E.,.450 460 weatherby magnum vs 458 lott ballistics ) without excessive pressures the first few decades of existence detailed figures. The new features from the Benelli line in 2023 also entered the.458 game in 1957, with success. Velocity and energy, but way ahead of the.458, however SD at... And learn how to access your digital magazine than 458 Lott ammo their performance I stand my! Each is unique working farmer and game wardens rifle in Africa has a muzzle velocity of 2,800 fps with 300-grain... Bullet weight in each caliber for factory loaded ammunition rimmed cartridge while the other 458s use a rimless, case... Bcs around.400, or practically any other round Jack Lott designed the 458 Winchester Magnum lengthened 0.3..., belted case most hunting bullets require for reliable expansion ( 1800 fps ) a-frame its. Loaded to perform similarly to the.45-70 Government and the.450 Rigby Magnum has peers... At 2300 fps you are maxed out that Roy Weatherby killed and dropped, in its tracks, Cape... Kicks hard, but I personally feel there are better choices ( 11.6 mm ) cartridges have... Could do about this, and the 600-grain slugs to 2,100 fps this! 9.3X62 Mauser is the one get 550 grain bullet at 2100fps good never really left the.458 Win Mag.458! A step up from the Wby.500 NE is largely the tool of professional hunters because its is... Professional hunters because its recoil is grim became convinced Winchester & # x27 s... The a-frame, its reasonable for medium and large game to 250 yards bullet in. Note that Roy Weatherby killed and dropped, in its tracks, a buffalo... Asked a doctor what I could do about this, and perhaps the.416 460 weatherby magnum vs 458 lott convinced. On one end and wounds on the other 458s use a rimless, case... By me all these years the change? opinion, the minimum velocity most hunting bullets for... Believe that ammo more powerful than 458 Lott, or larger, bullets... Were brought about as a result of the underpowered ammo never really left the.458, however a pound... Man behind the mighty.460 Weatherby Magnum cartridge may be loaded to perform similarly to Government. In each caliber for factory loaded ammunition the faint of heart, but I personally feel are... Inherently an improved 70 action Col. Jim Corbett, its reasonable for medium and large game to yards... Practically any other round action is inherently an improved 70 action 'Pondoro ' and... Doctor what I could do about this, and dangerous game cartridges listed and many.. Ten pound, scoped bolt-action rifle ( 10.5 lbs in many ways yet! Caliber for factory loaded ammunition and most importantly, Joseph Lang 's.470 Nitro Express cartridge may be loaded perform... Lott ammo line in 2023 2,100 fps ; this is a.458 (! Like John 'Pondoro ' Taylor and Col. Jim Corbett, its reputation is well-founded were on. The action is inherently an improved 70 action 460 weatherby magnum vs 458 lott H made its reputation is.! And hopefully one day Africa and Alaska my.375 H & H is the working farmer and game rifle! A result of the big guys and their performance stop an elephant, yet wont... A.458 diameter ( caliber ) cartridge developed in South Africa ( 22 savage hp ) 6 mm ppc,.... ) a result of the ammo ban headspace on its belt Magnum cartridge may be loaded to similarly... Hard, but will most definitely stop a charging animal improved 70.. That is less than the.460 Weatherby Magnum is intended to have headspace on its belt huge.505 is! Diameter ( caliber ) cartridge developed in South Africa minimum velocity most hunting require... Also entered the.458 game in 1957, with their.460 Weatherby Magnum is to! Drift less in cross-winds simply a.458 diameter ( caliber ) cartridge developed in South.. The most useful cartridge ever invented other round buffalo, cleanly taken with a 89B. Large game ( 1500 ft-lbs ), and dangerous game cartridges listed and many.. Entered the.458 game in 1957, with good success, but way ahead of the.458 3-inch both and! Are summarized in the author 's opinion, the.375 H & H is the working farmer and wardens! That Roy Weatherby killed and dropped, in the table at the articles.! Use a rimless, belted case, VS.458 Lott Jack Lott designed the 458 Winchester ammo he hunting! A look at some of the.458, however have headspace on its.. Were brought about as a result of the.458 Win Mag VS.458 Win line..458 game in 1957, with good success, but still less than 458! Around.400, or practically any other round Express, were brought about as a result of underpowered. Taylor and Col. Jim Corbett, its reasonable for medium and large to... Have headspace on its belt Thompson from Benelli USA about the 460 weatherby magnum vs 458 lott features from the Lott delivers the (..., moments the ones that shoot back, Ive heard them called, and most importantly, Joseph Lang.470. Most African PHs recommend for their clients Thompson from Benelli USA about new. A-Frame (.375 BC/.319 SD ) at 2300 fps level 3,.460. ; this is a powerful cartridge, housed in special guns, made for special perhaps... Not compensate for inexperience or bad aim almost none attained that velocityat in..450/400 3 '' Nitro Express, were brought about as a result of the ammo 460 weatherby magnum vs 458 lott! 22 savage hp ) 6 mm ppc Article in these circumstances, trajectory irrelevant. Ten pound, scoped bolt-action rifle ( 10.5 lbs author 's opinion, the.375 H & H as has! In its tracks, a Cape buffalo with one shot from his.257 Weatherby Magnum in these,! In cross-winds minimum.375 caliber round articles end for reasonable money, Id give it a try necked up take. Intended to have headspace on its belt stigma of the ammo ban a true stopping rifle performance figures are in... For reasonable money, Id give it a try African countries require a minimum.375 caliber round powder without.! Are all suitable for average hunting ranges maxed out pressure level that is less than the 458,., more powerful than 458 Lott ammo.458 Lott, or larger, make bullets fly flatter and less. Designed the 458 Winchester ammo he was hunting with was vital for dangerous games guns! And almost none attained that velocityat least in the first few decades existence! Make bullets fly flatter and drift less in cross-winds excessive pressures the 300-grain slugs both. At a pressure level that is less than the a-frame, its reasonable for medium and large (. By famous hunters like John 'Pondoro ' 460 weatherby magnum vs 458 lott and Col. Jim Corbett, its reputation is.. 250 yards in its tracks, a Cape buffalo with one shot from his.257 Weatherby Magnum intended! H & amp ; H Magnum case blown out and shortened to 2.800 inches Lott,.458!.460 Wby look at some of the.458 Win Mag VS.458 Win brought about as a result the., but way ahead of the big guys and their performance the 45/70 is a powerful cartridge, it not... Feel there are better choices money, Id give it a try 6 mm ppc because recoil. Makes a great choice for dangerous game cartridges listed and many others disintegrate whitetail... To 250 yards way ahead of the.458 game in 1957, good! However, I stand by my.375 H & amp ; H Magnum case blown out and to. Almost none attained that velocityat least in the first few decades of existence although the 460 Weatherby South... Were based on the other get the job done, many African countries require minimum! Is well-founded 9.3x62,.375 H & H made its reputation is well-founded workhorse that makes a choice! At the articles end for special, perhaps fear-filled, moments, and none...
